Auburn has produced 74 first-team All-Americans since Jimmy Hitchcock first won the honor in 1932. The NCAA recognizes selections from the AP, FWAA, AFCA, Sporting News and Walter Camp for consensus and unanimous All-Americans. Auburn has produced 30 consensus All-Americans and eight unanimous. The only jersey number we have been unable to track down is Jimmy Hitchcock.
| All-Americans by Jersey Number | |
|---|---|
| No. | Players |
| 2 | Cam Newton, Neil O'Donoghue |
| 4 | Junior Rosegreen, Chris Shelling |
| 5 | Lewis Colbert |
| 7 | Pat Sullivan |
| 11 | Chris Davis, Karlos Dansby, Bill Cody, Travis Tidwell |
| 12 | Jimmy Sidle, Tex Warrington |
| 14 | Carlos Rogers |
| 20 | Damon Duval, Brian Robinson, Tucker Frederickson |
| 21 | Tre Mason |
| 22 | Brent Fullwood |
| 23 | Fob James |
| 24 | Carnell Williams |
| 25 | Monk Gafford |
| 27 | Buddy McClinton |
| 28 | Bob Harris, Larry Willingham |
| 30 | Steven Clark |
| 33 | Walter Gilbert |
| 34 | Bo Jackson |
| 35 | Joe Childress |
| 38 | Terry Daniel, Ed Dyas |
| 39 | Kurt Crain |
| 42 | Mike Fuller |
| 50 | Reese Dismukes |
| 53 | Ken Bernich |
| 54 | Gregg Carr |
| 55 | Takeo Spikes, Ben Tamburello, Jackie Burkett |
| 60 | Stacy Searels |
| 61 | Zeke Smith |
| 67 | Ed King |
| 68 | Victor Riley |
| 69 | Ben Grubbs |
| 70 | David Campbell |
| 72 | Jack Thornton |
| 73 | Lee Ziemba, Marcus McNeill |
| 74 | Wayne Gandy, Tracy Rocker, |
| 75 | Ken Rice |
| 77 | Frank D'Agostino |
| 78 | Keith Uecker |
| 79 | Donnie Humphrey |
| 80 | Jim Pyburn |
| 81 | Frank Sanders |
| 86 | Walter Reeves |
| 88 | Terry Beasley, Freddy Hyatt, Jimmy Phillips |
| 90 | Nick Fairley |
| 93 | Aundray Bruce |
| 94 | Craig Ogletree |
| 95 | David Rocker |
| 96 | Benji Roland |